The Risks and Rewards of Compliance in Vehicle Reimbursement Programs
  • Home
  • Blog
  • The Risks and Rewards of Compliance in Vehicle Reimbursement Programs

The Risks and Rewards of Compliance in Vehicle Reimbursement Programs

Headshot of a man with a blurred background By Ben Reiland March 27, 2024

Categories: Vehicle Reimbursement

Compliance is about more than checking off boxes. It can help you build a strong foundation for your company and protect your business and employees. It turns out that compliance can be pretty lucrative, too! Considering the dreaded fines and penalties that come with non-compliance, following the rules can save you a lot of cash in the long run. 

If you’ve ever felt like navigating compliance is like trying to parallel park a semi-truck in a compact car space, you’re not alone. From the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA) to intricate IRS guidelines, it’s easy to feel lost regarding vehicle program compliance. That’s why we’re here to clarify the risks and rewards. So you understand what’s expected of you and your employees — and what’s at stake for non-compliance. 

Risks of Non-Compliance in Vehicle Reimbursement Programs

When you aren’t on top of compliance, you’re inviting legal headaches and financial trouble to your doorstep. Focusing on vehicle program compliance helps your company avoid legal and financial risks and uphold a healthy company culture. 

Legal Implications

State and federal regulatory violations can cause severe legal headaches. That’s why it’s important to know and abide by the vehicle program guidelines of the IRS and the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA).

Fair Labor Standards Act

The FLSA is designed to protect employees from unfair pay practices. With vehicle reimbursement, employers must reimburse non-exempt employees for the expenses they incur while using personal vehicles on the job. An employer violates the FLSA if the employee’s wage, subtracting employer-related expenses, is below the federal minimum wage. 

Here are the FLSA’s guidelines to be aware of:

  • Reasonable approximations: Employers can use “reasonable approximations” when calculating employee vehicle reimbursements if exact calculations aren’t realistic. The Department of Labor (DOL) considers any approach that reasonably reflects actual business expenses compliant. Your company needs clear and transparent policies for expense approximation to stay compliant. Establishing and following reasonable approximation processes for calculating employee vehicle expenses is paramount to compliance. 
  • FLSA-approved rates: While the IRS standard mileage rate is commonly used and preferred for vehicle reimbursement, it’s not the only one allowed under the Fair Labor Standards Act (FLSA). Employers can use rates lower than the IRS standard if they comply with FLSA guidelines. Regional factors such as fluctuating gas prices must also be considered when determining reimbursement rates. 
  • Fixed expense reimbursement: Employers are required to reimburse fixed vehicle expenses if the vehicle is predominantly used for the employer’s benefit.

You should regularly review and adjust reimbursement methods as needed to accommodate changing business needs and regional cost variations.

Potential Labor Law Violations

As an employer, you should also understand what constitutes a violation of labor laws. This understanding can help you avoid legal consequences such as penalties, fines, lawsuits and damage to your company’s reputation. 

  • Reimbursement failure: You might violate labor laws if you fail to reimburse employees for the expenses of using personal vehicles during employment. This can result in wages falling below the federal minimum wage.
  • Unapproved reimbursement methods: Using reimbursement methods that don’t meet FLSA criteria may violate labor law. These include failing to provide reasonable approximations or using rates lower than the IRS standard without meeting FLSA guidelines.
  • Poor record-keeping: Maintaining accurate reimbursement records with mileage tracking and expense documentation is essential in maintaining compliance with labor laws and avoiding penalties.
  • Non-compliance with state regulations: Complying with state labor laws regarding expense reimbursements is as important as complying with federal law. Failure to adhere to state-specific requirements can lead to legal consequences.
  • Not reimbursing fixed expenses: If employees are required to use personal vehicles as a “tool of the trade,” employers must reimburse fixed vehicle expenses. Failure to do so may result in violations, especially if the vehicle is primarily used for the employer’s benefit.
  • Employee misclassification: If you attempt to misclassify employees as independent contractors to get around expense reimbursements, you may face labor law violations and legal repercussions.

IRS Guidelines on Accountable Plans

An accountable plan is a plan that reimburses an employee for expenses when the following conditions are met: 

  • There is a business reason for the expenses
  • The expenses are substantiated
  • Employees return amounts above substantiated expenses within a reasonable time

If your plan doesn’t meet these conditions or employees aren’t adhering to the policy the IRS may consider it non-accountable, making reimbursements taxable. To comply with the IRS you must collect taxes on non-accountable plans and follow the correct processes on accountable plans to substantiate business use. 

Tax Penalties and Liabilities

Failure to comply with IRS guidelines for accountable plans or to adequately reimburse employees for business-related vehicle expenses can lead to several consequences:

  • The reimbursed amounts may be considered taxable income for the employees, which can lead to financial burdens for both the employee and employer.
  • Employers who are non-compliant with the IRS may also lose tax deductions associated with vehicle reimbursements. This results in increased taxable income and higher tax liabilities for the employer.
  • Non-compliance with IRS regulations for accountable plans and expense reimbursements can trigger audits and penalties. 
  • Employers may incur legal costs from defending against IRS audits or employee lawsuits resulting from non-compliance with tax laws. 
  • Employers may be required to pay settlements or judgments if liable for improperly handling vehicle reimbursements. 
  • Employers may lose certain tax benefits or incentives for tax non-compliance, including credits or previously available exemptions.

Keeping Accurate Records

Mileage tracking and expense documentation promote accurate, compliant reimbursements for employees using personal vehicles for business. If you aren’t already doing these things, here are a few reasons to start: 

  • The IRS needs detailed records: The IRS requires detailed documentation to substantiate business-related expenses, including mileage, to ensure reimbursements aren’t considered taxable income for employees.
  • Tracking expenses leads to savings: By tracking mileage and expenses, organizations can identify areas where costs can be reduced or optimized and compound savings.
  • Record-keeping improves compliance: Maintaining accurate mileage and expense records helps organizations comply with labor laws and regulations governing expense reimbursement. 
  • Having documentation promotes transparency: Transparent mileage tracking and expense documentation ensure fairness in reimbursement processes. It demonstrates that reimbursements are based on actual business use for a fair, equitable work environment.

We recommend utilizing technology and encouraging employees to keep detailed records to simplify mileage tracking and expense documentation. Establish regular reporting procedures, review and audit reports, and provide training to ensure compliance with company policies and IRS regulations.

Financial Risk

Non-compliance with vehicle reimbursement programs can pose a significant risk to a company’s bottom line. Establishing compliant programs is crucial for companies to avoid fines and penalties. 

Tax Savings Through Accountable Plans

With accountable plans, employees get reimbursed for their business expenses and don’t have to pay taxes on that money. Employees end up with a lower tax bill because they don’t have to report reimbursement as income on their taxes. This puts more money back in their pockets, making the whole reimbursement process smoother and more efficient for them and the company. 

Plus, since the plan follows IRS guidelines it ensures compliance and reduces the risk of audits or penalties. It’s a simple yet powerful way to save money and streamline operations, and it’s a win-win for everyone.

Inaccurate Reimbursements Lead to Budgetary Issues

When reimbursements don’t accurately reflect an employee’s actual expenses, it can throw a wrench in your company’s budgeting process. Inaccurate reimbursements can create unexpected costs for employers and employees, financial strain and disruption. 

For employers, this can mean unexpected financial burdens, as they may need to designate extra funds to cover the true costs of business-related expenses. On the other hand, employees may face financial strain if they aren’t adequately reimbursed for expenses they already paid out of pocket. 

These budgetary issues can disrupt financial planning and stress employer-employee relationships. Accurate reimbursement processes are central to maintaining financial stability and employee satisfaction.

Long-Term Financial Stability

Implementing compliant vehicle reimbursement programs also contributes to long-term financial stability. Predictable budgeting becomes easier when expenses are accurately accounted for and reduces the likelihood of unexpected financial setbacks. By avoiding the unforeseen costs of non-compliance, companies can maintain financial stability and allocate resources effectively for sustainable growth and long-term success.

Company Culture

Being fair with vehicle reimbursements and following compliance rules isn’t just good for your company’s bottom line — it’s good for morale, too. Fair reimbursements show your company cares and keeps employees feeling respected, valued and happy. 

They also contribute to increased employee satisfaction, motivation and loyalty. And because fair reimbursement policies contribute to a positive workplace culture and employee experience, they can attract great talent and retain existing workers. When people are happy at work, everyone wins.

Employee Compliance Risks

Drivers using personal vehicles for work also have an important role in compliance. They need to have the right insurance, which should be current. If they don’t, things can get messy when accidents happen; making sure driver insurance is up to date helps protect everyone involved. 

Here are the insurance requirements to understand if you’re a driver involved in a reimbursement program:

  1. Liability coverage: This coverage protects drivers if they’re at fault in an accident and need to cover damages or injuries to others. It pays for damages or injuries inflicted by the employee/driver in an accident, including property damage and bodily injury. The amount required varies by state and employer policy but must meet the state’s minimum requirements. 
  2. Personal injury protection (PIP): PIP makes sure everyone involved in an accident gets prompt medical treatment and compensation for lost income due to injuries — regardless of fault. Requiring drivers to have PIP insurance coverage helps employers mitigate the financial risks of accidents, ensuring drivers are adequately protected in unforeseen circumstances.
  3. Comprehensive and collision coverage: Collision coverage pays for damage from hitting an object or another car. Comprehensive coverage pays for damage to the employee/driver’s vehicle caused by non-collision incidents like natural disasters or vandalism. 

Proper insurance coverage protects both the employer and the employee from financial liabilities in an accident involving an uninsured driver. It covers medical expenses, vehicle repairs, and other related costs, ultimately reducing the risk of legal disputes and financial strain on both parties.

As an employer, you should always verify and maintain records of employee coverage to ensure they meet the required standards. This helps mitigate the risks of uninsured drivers and ensures everyone has the coverage to protect themselves and others after accidents.

Benefits of a Comprehensive Compliance Program

Following compliance requirements closely can benefit employers and employees greatly. Compliance reduces legal and financial risks, such as fines, liabilities, insurance-related costs and lawsuits, enhancing the brand’s image. 

Compliant businesses have better reputations with the public as they demonstrate the organization’s commitment to ethical and legal standards. This reputation also helps them attract and keep good employees who value ethical business practices, leading to satisfaction, trust and mutual respect between the company and its workers. All of these are necessary for an organization’s long-term success.

Implementing a Compliant Vehicle Reimbursement Program

If you’re in the process of implementing a vehicle reimbursement program, here are some important tips to keep in mind for compliance purposes:

  • Identify experienced vehicle program vendors: Do your research while shopping vendors to find one with a proven track record of compliant vehicle reimbursement solutions. Look for those with experience in regulatory requirements and reliable services.
  • Adhere to regulations: Stay current with federal and state regulations governing vehicle reimbursement programs. This will help you keep your program compliant with all applicable laws and guidelines and avoid legal issues and penalties.
  • Customize plans to organizational needs: Customize your reimbursement plans to suit your organization’s needs and preferences. When designing your program, consider factors such as employee driving patterns, budget constraints and company culture.
  • Use technology for accurate tracking: Technology can streamline mileage tracking and expense management processes and ultimately reduce liability. Look for user-friendly, widely compatible apps with features like GPS tracking and expense categorization that employees can use to track mileage and business expenses easily. Invest in software solutions or mobile apps like Motus’s that offer automated tracking, real-time reporting and secure data storage to promote accuracy and efficiency. 

Following these steps and finding the right tools and resources helps you implement a compliant vehicle reimbursement program tailored to your organization’s needs. You’ll also be able to adhere to regulatory requirements easily.

Simplify Vehicle Program Compliance With Motus

Clearly, the risks of non-compliance in vehicle programs are significant — and not worth taking. Don’t let hefty fines, reputational damage, unexpected costs or lawsuits come knocking on your door. Instead, consider investing in technology that makes compliance second nature for smoother operations, happier employees and a healthier bottom line.

If you want to improve your compliance and optimize your vehicle reimbursement program effortlessly, take a tour of the Motus platform today. Our solutions can help you stay compliant while gaining visibility, control and savings. With our simple yet powerful tools, you can streamline processes, automate tasks and adapt to changing regulatory requirements with ease. Contact us now to start mastering compliance!

Contact Us

We make getting started easy.

We make getting started easy.

Contact us today or take a virtual tour of the Motus Platform.

Take A Tour